Yesterday I wished Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay a happy fortieth birthday. Today, I got to wish myself a happy 52nd one, and it’s been a nice treat to get to write about Trench Crusade after enjoying a very leisurely breakfast in bed from the kiddos and a day of general rest and relaxation. A little coffee in the cup, a bit of Nachtblut on the speaker, and here we go (if a bit later than usual today).
I tried something different this past week here on the Wordforge. Up until now I’ve used the Wednesday publishing slot to offer Warhammer-based content, but this time around I penned a piece on the subject of Trench Crusade and merchandising… and stumbled into a minefield.
Let’s unpack that for a minute, because I think it reveals something fascinating about the soul of the Trench Crusade fandom. And it also happily coincided with the game’s next big licensing reveal.
To Merch or Not To Merch
The tension between commercialism and art is a relatively newer phenomenon, one that reflects the rise in esteem of the creative class and the fruits of their labors and imaginings. The advent of the printing press and rise of literacy rates expanded the conversation around who literature was ‘meant’ for, as the motive force for commercial content moved away from the aristocratic patronage system and more aligned with a market-driven economy. It was, in that sense- and for better or for worse- democratized.
These days, you’ll often find that tension playing out in the music scene and the idea of bands “selling out.” From Metallica’s Black album to Bad Religion leaving Epitaph for Atlantic, I’ve been a part of scenes where this is a significant test of integrity. So it was immediately familiar when I ran afoul of it in the Trench Crusade community.
What was particularly interesting, though, is where the battle lines were drawn.
Reddit: The Reckoning
This was where my article took a bit of a beating, with downvoting leaving little doubt as to what they thought of TC merchandising. The comments were fairly unsparing:
“I'm not gonna lie, most of this stuff feels like tacky consumerist junk. Part of the appeal of Trench Crusade to me, and others, is that it is NOT 40k.”
“The only thing I could endorse would be the paper magazine. The other things just seem to be things to grab cash from fans, cheap stuff sold to us above price for a profit and kind of goes against the do it yourself mentallity that the game tried to revive a little. The last one though, that is just selling junk. It is mostly creating a need that was not there to begin with. There is already enough of this going around. Wishing for more of this kind of consumerism is unhealthy.”
“I would love to not see anything outside the tabletop. I think dice, measuring sticks, tokens etc. are fine, though I use just regular dice and a tape-measure.”
Huh. Well, I posted the piece over on the Trench Crusade and Trench Crusade North America groups, how was it faring over there?
Facebook: Business as Usual
This was a lot more in line with what I’d been an expecting- an enthusiasm for the property that would translate into extra ways to express that.
“They had a great selection of shirts that are sadly no longer available it seems.”
“Banners for each faction.”
“Just keeping it simple would suffice really. Like mugs, posters, clothing, key rings, dice etc. Maybe the odd statue of the more iconic units like the artillery witch. I'd avoid items like action figures, plushies and funko pops as it would undermine the brand slightly. Like with 40k I feel the moment they started doing plush nurglings it robbed the setting of some of its aura.”
“Would love to see a TTRPG.”
“I’d like to see novels. I don’t need epic heroes, just tales from the trenches.”
And the last one I’ll excerpt with attribution here, because Zach Pennington went into a fair amount of depth:
“The only direction that Trench Crusade needs to take in regards to Warhammer is the opposite one. We have a WONDERFUL community full of proxy makers, story tellers and variety, and I think that in and of itself is what brings this community together like it is. We all look at each other‘s work and we help each other out.
“So don’t get me wrong Warhammer may have paved the way for this, but their current direction is cheeks and needs to be stayed far away from because it’s the exact thing that a community of gamers doesn’t want..too much rigidity and too little creativity and variety.
“I do like the idea of the acrylic displays. I think that’s wonderful. That’s definitely something I would like because it quick as I get these painted I do put them up for sale, but sometimes they sit here and collect dust. I think you’re spot on in your article.
“I personally would like to have some more complete lore, especially when it comes to some of these characters that are more just outliers and not really playable characters. I would like to see them more developed into some playable characters.”
So… a tale of two communities, then, at least inasmuch as you can generalize based on the feedback available. And if it seems like I’m being critical of the Reddit group, know that I don’t have to necessarily agree with their position in order to respect it. It’s clear they have a strong passion for the game, and a concern that it risks losing its way if it takes its focus off its core concern. If we start seeing Trench Crusade spatulas or pajamas or stuffed plushies, I’ll be right there with them.
But the four things I recommended: a short story/game scenario periodical (PDF or paper), acrylic miniature and model displays, quality display artwork, and a range of trinkets and curios a la Starforge, well, those are part of a property’s core concern and I stand by them.
If I erred here, it was in framing the article as “what we can learn” from the success of Warhammer1. That was dumb, and severely under-considered the allergy many in the community have for Games Workshop. It was a useful reminder, too, that the reputation I’ve built up in the Black Library community over the past couple years- that of someone who is passionate about a property while also centering the consumer experience- is not automatically transferable to another.
It must be re-earned, and I appreciate that lesson.
Trench Crusade Revelations
Now, here’s the fun part. In the midst of the conversation the article spawned, a few neat tidbits shook out of the information tree. I’ve spoken before about how Tuomas Pirinen seems to keep his fingers very close to the pulse of the Trench Crusade community, and here again we saw further evidence of that.
Here he was on Facebook, addressing the disappearance of officially-licensed wearables.

Meanwhile, in a post responding to my sharing of the merch article on Bluesky, Pirinen also dropped some exciting news about a new release from Mindworks:
Sure enough, a quick trip to the Mindworks store showed not one, but three new releases:
A 1:9-scale bust of the Jabirean Alchemist, sculpted by Akshay Kumar
A Prussian Hauptmann, in both 1:20-scale full body and 1:9-scale bust, sculpted by Antonio Marzii
Best of all, both Hauptmann options include a head option for Frederica Von Goltz, which is music to my ears as I prefer to display named characters where I can in my museum builds.
Both the Alchemist bust and full-body Hauptmann are listed as Limited Editions on the Mindworks site, limited to 300 units. They also are available for preorder at a discounted price through 25 November, so if you’re keen for one (or more), it’s advisable to take advantage.
A Donation to the Cause
As I’ve been covering Trench Crusade, one of the nagging questions I’ve had is, how the hell did I not get in on this earlier? Sure, I’ve had a lot of things to deal with these last two years that tower far above gaming, but it’s been a genuine puzzle.
This past week, I solved it. Turns out, apparently I didn’t.
When I logged into Kickstarter this week to back a board game I just couldn’t resist, One Thousand Rats Devour a City, a moment of idle curiosity drove me to check my backer history. Sure enough, it looks like I indeed had pledged in on the initial Trench Crusade.
Figuring I had nothing to lose, I rolled the dice.

If bad news travels halfway around the world before good news even puts its boots on, that was certainly true here. Note that this was a same-day reply!
That was hardly surprising. The first few months of my wife’s cancer diagnosis were a whirlwind, with a lot of balls getting dropped as we struggled to adjust to the battle ahead. I could hardly be miffed that they hadn’t kept a copy back in reserve in the odd chance that- almost two years later- I might randomly surface and expect it to be there.
I bring this up mainly as another exhibit of how well Factory Fortress appears to be managing the details of running the business. A three to five day turnaround is fairly standard stuff and raises few eyebrows.
Two very courteous and professional replies in two days, for a secondary contact account? Eyebrows were definitely raised, and in the good way.
Take a bow, customer service department!
ICYMI
Here’s what’s been going on this week for Trench Crusade content!
Trench Crusade Official
Some business up-front, the official Carcass Front Rules Commentary and Errata went live this week.
Graham McNeill’s back in the lore saddle again this week, with the upcoming Prussian Yeomen getting their moment in the sun. Martin McCoy provided the art!
The Army Painter’s Brand Commander, Adam Abramowicz, offered up a painting guide to the Hell Knight this week.
Speaking of painting, Dave Taylor took readers on a tour of some paint schemes that offered up a splash of vibrant color instead of hewing closely to the grimdark aesthetic.
Jon Wimpeney, possibly (or possibly not) a member of the Trench Crusade Illuminati, penned a piece on the strategic risks and rewards of exploring during a campaign.
Wargame Content Sites
Some guy named Jay Kirkman wrote a review for Tabletop Battles of two of Trench Crusade’s short fiction stories, penned by Graham McNeill and Gav Thorpe. Oh wait, that’s me! Hope you enjoyed.
It was a two-fer this week at TTB, with an in-depth examination of the High Cathedra of Pride warband by dgmp.
Community Content
The Saints & Sevens Podcast continued its deep dive into the Court of the Seven Headed Serpent, this time with a look at the different Sins.
Meanwhile, the Trench Scribe Podcast came at things from the other direction with this overview of the Procession of the Sacred Affliction.
AmyArtBizarre got her hands on the Carcass Front box, and recorded a terrific brief overview!
Coming Attractions
Here’s a list of the known upcoming physical releases from Trench Crusade based on the available preorder information we have.
This section will be updated weekly in this column, with new or updated info presented in boldface.
Trench Crusade Rulebook (hardcover, 11/30)
That’s it for this week, see you again in seven days’ time!
I also should have made it clearer that I wasn’t looking at the “Games Workshop playbook” as an unvarnished good for Trench Crusade. There are thematic similarities in the properties, but that doesn’t mean Factory Fortress would be well-served following unquestioningly in the footsteps of Games Workshop.









Happy birthday!!!!